Thursday, March 24, 2005

23 things I don't like  

A blogger I read regularly once posted a list of things he or she hates. I think it was Miss O'Hara, but I couldn't find the post in question on her site, so I might be wrong. Anyway, I'm stealing picking up that idea and listing 23 things I don't particularly like or strongly dislike. In no particular order:


Jenna asked in the comments why I so dislike the way Disney ruined Winnie-the-Pooh. Let me say that the Pooh books are my favorite books. They, after the Bible, would be my desert island books, if I had a choice. When Disney got the rights to the stories, the company turned rich characters into cheery, one-dimensional caricatures devoid of any real personality and thereby robbed the stories of any style whatsoever. Take for instance this exchange (gleaned from IMDB) from the Disney movie Winnie-the-Pooh and Tigger Too! after Tigger and Roo have become stuck at the top of a tall tree.

Christopher Robin: You're next, Tigger. Jump!
Tigger: Jump? Tiggers don't jump. They bounce.
Pooh: Then bounce down.
Tigger: Oh, don't be ridickerous. Tiggers only bounce up!
Christopher Robin: You can climb down, Tigger.
Tigger: Uh, Tiggers can't climb down, uh... because, uh... their tails get in the way!
Rabbit: Hooray! That settles it. If he won't jump, and he can't climb down, then we'll just have to leave him up there FOREVER!

I guess the people in charge at Disney thought that was funny. Here's a scene from the same basic story in The House at Pooh Corner, Chapter IV, In Which It Is Shown That Tiggers Don't Climb Trees:

Christopher Robin looked up at Tigger and Roo, and tried to think of something.

"I thought," said Piglet earnestly, "that if Eeyore stood at the bottom of the tree, and if Pooh stood on Eeyore's back, and if I stood on Pooh's shoulders—"

"And if Eeyore's back snapped suddenly, then we could all laugh. Ha ha! Amusing in a quiet way," said Eeyore, "but not really helpful."

"Well," said Piglet meekly, "I thought—"

"Would it break your back, Eeyore?" asked Pooh, very much surprised.

"That's what would be so interesting, Pooh. Not being quite sure till afterwards."

Judge for yourself whether Disney captured or even respected the spirit of the source material.